Hindutva, Ram Setu, and Marine Ecology

by Amrit Hallan on May 28, 2007

It has to be nasty when “Hindu” organizations get involved. These bloody fascists need to be taught a lesson, even if for that you have to cut your own arm. Our progressive central and state governments are planning to demolish the Ram Setu to make way for the ambitious Sethusamudram project that is going to connect the Bay of Bengal with the Indian Ocean (Gulf of Mannar and Palk Bay). A ship canal will be dug, I think somewhat similar to what they did when they created the Suez Canal. This will significantly reduce the shipping time, as right now all the ships have to come round Sri Lanka.

It’s irrelevant how much money the canal is going to save. It is also irrelevant that the vanar sena (the monkey army of Lord Ram) laid the millions of stones so that they could reach Lanka and rescue Sita from the demon king Rawan. What’s relevant is the ecological, geographic and oceanic effect the project is going to unleash. This is what some of the experts say:

Retired marine scientists and experts claim that if the Government persists with the project in its present form, India could be inviting an ecological disaster. They cite the 2004 experience of the coastline protected by Ram Setu escaping the fury of the Boxing Day tsunami.

Destroying the setu, they point out, citing tsunami expert Tad S Murthy, “Opens up serious potential damage to the entire Kerala and Tamil Nadu coast when the next tsunami occurs.” The project does not factor in measures to protect the coastline from tsunamis after the existing barrier is destroyed.

Experts have pointed out that as a consequence of dredging and opening of Ram Setu, fragile coral islands will be “destroyed by sediments and turbulent tides of Bay of Bengal entering the tranquil Gulf of Mannar.” They have suggested that the channel should be realigned towards Pamban and, like the Panama Canal, locks could be provided at the Palk Bay end and the Gulf of Mannar end to prevent disasters like tsunamis.

And this is where religion gets involved:

It is ironical that a government which changes the metro rail route to protect the Qutub Minar, built with the material of destroyed temples, stops a corridor to protect the Taj Mahal’s surroundings and spends crores of rupees to showcase ancient potteries and jewellery in heavily guarded museums, is destroying a unique symbol of national identity and an icon well preserved in our minds since ages. Even a child knows that a bridge was built by the friends of Lord Rama using floating stones and Rama’s army marched over it to Lanka to rescue Sita and destroy the evil regime of Ravana. [link]

This is sad. I’m not saying the monuments and historical artifacts belonging to the “great Mughal period” shouldn’t be protected — of course they should be protected because they are a part of our heritage — but then why be so callous about the Ram Setu, which officially the government calls the ”Adam’s bridge”? Just because the bridge bears Hindu connotations, it doesn’t mean it deserves no protection. So I fully support the VHP campaign to save the bridge – sometimes the end does justify the means. It’s disastrous that destructive organizations like the VHP is doing something that the civil society should do.

Here you can find more information on Ram Setu, or Ram Sethu.

[tags]sethusamudram project, ram setu, ram sethu, vhp, hindutva, hindu[/tags]

  • http://www.tech-times.net/blog/ecology/index.php/2007/05/28/hindutva-ram-setu-and-marine-ecology/ ecology » Blog Archive » Hindutva, Ram Setu, and Marine Ecology

    [...] …more [...]

  • Ramki

    Ram Setu is a myth. THere is no substancial evidence for the existence of the bridge. Carbon dating by NASA say that sand portion between India and Srilanka formed before 1.8 million years. Where as Ramayana happenedd few thousand years back. VHP is just trying to get political mileage out of it.

  • http://www.tech-times.net/blog/ecology/index.php/2007/05/28/bacteria-in-outer-space-exchange-experience-rapid-change-2/ ecology » Blog Archive » Bacteria in outer space exchange experience rapid change

    [...] It has to be nasty when Hindu organizations get involved. These bloody fascists need to be taught a lesson, even if for that you have to cut your own arm. Our progressive central and state governments are planning to demolish the Ram … …more [...]

  • Arjun

    Dear Ramki,
    Ram Setu is not a myth. Fact is -

    1. NASA found a bridge between India and Lanka and says that the formation is man-made, not natural.

    2. It says that this formation is 1.8 million years old.

    So where’s the myth ? The structure exists.

    And just for your kind information, Ramayana did not happen a few thousands of years back, the Mahabharata did. Around 5500 years back, the battle was fought on Kurukshetra. The Ramayana is much, much older. Know about the four Yugas ? No ? I thought so.

  • http://www.amrithallan.com Amrit

    Ramki: Yes, the VHP is getting political mileage out of but this is not my main concern. Let them get all the mileage they want. The main point is the Ram Setu bridge. If it is demolished, the marine ecology of straight will be disturbed.

    Arjun: It’s been a consistent campaign of the left to prove that Ramayana and Mahabharata never happened. I’m not sure if they happened or not but they have lived in the psyche of an entire civilization so it cannot be entirely bogus.

  • http://www.tech-times.net/blog/ecology/index.php/2007/05/31/attention-this-is-god-speaking/ ecology » Blog Archive » Attention- This is GOD speaking

    [...] It has to be nasty when Hindu organizations get involved. These bloody fascists need to be taught a lesson, even if for that you have to cut your own arm. Our progressive central and state governments are planning to demolish the Ram … …more [...]

  • Captain Ashwani

    I am strongly against when you that “Ram Setu” is a myth. You must first check the truth than only critisize any thing. It is not myth it is a true fact as i have met people who have seen it from there own eyes.

  • ravi

    when some one is doing a good job of repairing the mosque in j & k a fatwa is issued and immediately you stop the work. But these polititian will not listen to when some one says dont distroy Ram Setu.They will not go into the details and insted will be adament to carryon the work. That is the present situation in India.

  • http://www.amrithallan.com Amrit

    It’s just to please certain communities and ideologies, nothing very intriguing.

Previous post:

Next post: